Bohr Model Masterclass · Vidya720
Physics · Class 12 Atoms · NEET

The atom that should have collapsed, and how Bohr saved it

A full lesson: a cartoon movie to start, then why an orbiting electron should spiral into the nucleus, Bohr's three postulates, quantised angular momentum, the radius, speed and energy of the nth orbit, the n-trend machine, hydrogen-like ions, NEET shortcuts, problems to solve yourself, and 12 MCQs.

NCERT Class 12 Physics Part II · Ch 12 Atoms · Bohr model of the hydrogen atom · pp. 297–299 · about 60 min

Voice
About 6 minutes. The animations start by themselves as the teacher explains them. Each stage's Listen button uses the same language.

A ball on a string that winds round a pole always ends up at the pole. Classical physics says an orbiting electron should do the same within about 10⁻¹¹ s. Atoms do not collapse, so Bohr made new rules: only certain orbits are allowed, and light comes out only when the electron jumps between them.

Stage 1 · The hook (5 min)

The ball that always hits the pole

Level

In the school ground, Arjun ties a ball to a rope fixed at the top of a pole and hits it round and round. With every turn the rope wraps around the pole, the circle gets smaller, the ball goes faster, and finally it thuds into the pole. His cousin Riya laughs: "It always ends at the pole!"

In Rutherford's atom the electron goes round the nucleus, and classical physics says it should behave like Arjun's ball: lose energy, spiral inwards and crash into the nucleus. Yet the hydrogen in a star or in a discharge tube is perfectly stable and glows with sharp lines. In 1913 Niels Bohr solved this puzzle with three bold rules.

Teacher says

"When a theory predicts something that never happens, the theory has to change. Here, classical electromagnetism predicts that every atom should collapse. Bohr kept the nuclear atom but added quantum rules."

Pause and predict

"As Arjun's ball winds inwards, it goes round faster and faster. If the ball were a charge giving out light at its rotation frequency, what colours would come out?"

Answer (we use this idea in Stage 2)

Every colour in turn, sliding smoothly from one frequency to the next: a continuous spectrum. Real atoms give only sharp lines, which is the second failure of the classical picture.

Stage 2 · The concept (10 min)

Why the classical nuclear atom cannot survive

Level

An electron in a circular orbit is always accelerating towards the centre. Classical electromagnetic theory says an accelerated charge radiates energy. So the orbit should shrink, the electron should spiral into the nucleus, and the frequency of the emitted light should change smoothly. Run the classical prediction, then compare it with real hydrogen.

Failure 1: stability

accelerated charge radiates

Losing energy, the electron spirals in. A classical estimate gives a lifetime of about 10⁻¹¹ s.

Failure 2: spectrum

classical: ν = v / 2πr, changing smoothly

A smooth change of frequency means a continuous spectrum, not sharp lines.

The facts

emission lines = absorption lines

Each gas emits a line fingerprint; white light through the same gas shows dark lines at the same wavelengths.

Teacher says

"Two predictions, two failures: the atom should collapse, and the spectrum should be continuous. Neither happens. So classical ideas cannot be applied unchanged inside the atom."

Stage 3 · The law (10 min)

Bohr's three postulates

Level

In 1913 Bohr combined classical ideas with the early quantum hypothesis. Step through the three postulates. In postulate 2, slide the orbit radius and see that only special radii have an angular momentum that is a whole number of h/2π.

  1. Stationary orbits

    certain orbits: no radiation

    An electron can revolve in certain stable orbits without emitting energy. Each orbit has a definite total energy.

  2. Quantised angular momentum

    L = m v r = n h / 2π, n = 1, 2, 3, …

    Only orbits whose angular momentum is an integer multiple of h/2π are allowed. n is the principal quantum number.

  3. Frequency condition

    h ν = E_i − E_f (E_i > E_f)

    Light is emitted only when the electron jumps from a higher orbit to a lower one, as one photon. Absorbing a photon of exactly the right energy lifts it up.

Teacher says

"Postulate 1 says no radiation in an allowed orbit. Postulate 2 tells you which orbits are allowed. Postulate 3 says light comes only from jumps. Emission needs a drop to lower energy; going up needs absorption."

Stage 4 · Maths (10 min)

Radius, speed and energy of the nth orbit

Level

Combine the force equation of Lesson 2 with Bohr's angular momentum rule and everything about the orbit follows. Pick the orbit number n and watch the radius, the speed and the energy level.

  1. Two equations

    m v² / r = e² / (4πε₀ r²) and m v r = n h / 2π

    Force balance (classical) and angular momentum rule (quantum).

  2. Speed

    v_n = e² / (2ε₀ h n) ≈ 2.2 × 10⁶ / n m/s

    Divide the first by the second. The speed falls as 1/n.

  3. Radius

    r_n = n² h² ε₀ / (π m e²) = n² a₀, a₀ = 0.53 Å

    a₀ is the Bohr radius. Second orbit 4a₀, third 9a₀.

  4. Energy

    E_n = −e² / (8πε₀ r_n) = −13.6 / n² eV

    Lowest (most negative) for n = 1, rising towards 0 as n grows. The minus sign means the electron is bound.

Teacher says

"Radius n squared, speed one over n, energy minus one over n squared. Remember also: minus 0.85 eV is a higher energy than minus 3.4 eV, even though 0.85 is the smaller number."

Stage 5 · The big idea (10 min)

The n-trend machine

Level

Most NEET questions on Bohr's model are ratio questions. Choose a quantity and two orbits; the machine plots the quantity for n = 1 to 6 and computes the ratio for you. Then try to beat it in your head.

QuantityDepends on n asn = 1 value (hydrogen)
radius rn²0.53 Å
speed v1/n2.2 × 10⁶ m/s
energy E−1/n²−13.6 eV
ang. momentum Lnh/2π = 1.05 × 10⁻³⁴ J s
time period T = 2πr/vn³1.5 × 10⁻¹⁶ s
Teacher says

"Write the power of n first, then the ratio is just arithmetic. Radius from n equals 1 to 3: three squared, nine times. Energy: minus 13.6 becomes minus 13.6 over 9, closer to zero."

Pause and predict

"Is the energy needed to take the electron from n = 1 to n = 2 bigger or smaller than from n = 2 to n = 3?"

Answer (this leads into Lesson 4)

Bigger. 1 → 2 needs 13.6 − 3.4 = 10.2 eV; 2 → 3 needs 3.4 − 1.51 = 1.89 eV. The levels crowd together as n grows. These gaps give the lines of the hydrogen spectrum.

Stage 6 · Real life (5 min)

Beyond hydrogen: He⁺, Li²⁺ and the stars

Level

Bohr's model works for any atom with a single electron: hydrogen, singly ionised helium He⁺ (Z = 2), doubly ionised lithium Li²⁺ (Z = 3). A bigger nuclear charge pulls the electron closer and binds it more tightly. Very hot stars contain He⁺, and astronomers see its lines in their spectra.

Radius

r = 0.53 n² / Z Å

He⁺ ground state: 0.265 Å, half of hydrogen's.

Energy

E = −13.6 Z² / n² eV

He⁺ ground state: −54.4 eV. Li²⁺: −122.4 eV.

Speed

v = 2.2 × 10⁶ Z / n m/s

The electron in Li²⁺ (n = 1) moves at 6.6 × 10⁶ m/s.

Stage 7 · NEET level (10 min)

Shortcuts and tricks

Level

The power table

r ∝ n²/Z, v ∝ Z/n, E ∝ −Z²/n²

Also L ∝ n, T ∝ n³/Z², frequency of revolution ∝ Z²/n³.

Energy family

K = −E, U = 2E

For n = 1: K = 13.6 eV, U = −27.2 eV, E = −13.6 eV.

Angular momentum

L = n h / 2π

Third orbit: 3h/2π, not 9h/2π. L grows as n, not n².

Photon energy

hν = E_i − E_f

3 → 2 gives 1.89 eV (656 nm, red); 2 → 1 gives 10.2 eV (122 nm, ultraviolet).

Ionisation

from level n: 13.6 Z² / n² eV

Hydrogen from n = 1: 13.6 eV; from n = 2: 3.4 eV.

Higher energy?

−0.85 > −3.4 > −13.6

Closer to zero means higher. The ground state has the lowest energy.

Teacher says

"Learn the power table and you can answer any Bohr ratio in ten seconds. And never forget the sign: the energy is negative, and it increases towards zero as n increases."

Stage 8 · Solve it yourself

Five worked problems

Level

Cover the solution, write the formula, and solve on paper. Open the hint only if you are stuck for more than a minute. Use a₀ = 0.53 Å, h = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ J s.

Problem 1 · The third orbit

For the electron in the n = 3 orbit of hydrogen, find r, E, v and L.

Hint

r = n²a₀, E = −13.6/n², v = 2.2 × 10⁶/n, L = nh/2π.

Full solution
r = 9 × 0.53 = 4.77 Å
E = −13.6 / 9 = −1.51 eV
v = 2.2 × 10⁶ / 3 = 7.3 × 10⁵ m/s
L = 3 × 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ / 2π = 3.17 × 10⁻³⁴ J s
4.77 Å, −1.51 eV, 7.3 × 10⁵ m/s, 3h/2π
Problem 2 · Which orbit?

In which orbit of hydrogen is the radius 8.48 Å?

Hint

n² = r / a₀.

Full solution
n² = 8.48 / 0.53 = 16
n = 4
Problem 3 · Energy for a jump

How much energy is needed to lift the electron of hydrogen from n = 1 to n = 2? What photon is emitted when it falls back?

Hint

ΔE = E₂ − E₁; λ (nm) ≈ 1240 / E (eV).

Full solution
E₂ − E₁ = −3.4 − (−13.6) = 10.2 eV
λ = 1240 / 10.2 ≈ 122 nm
10.2 eV absorbed; on falling back, a 10.2 eV ultraviolet photon (≈ 122 nm)
Problem 4 · Hydrogen-like ion

Find the radius and energy of the ground state of He⁺ (Z = 2).

Hint

r = 0.53 n²/Z, E = −13.6 Z²/n².

Full solution
r = 0.53 × 1 / 2 = 0.265 Å
E = −13.6 × 4 / 1 = −54.4 eV
0.265 Å and −54.4 eV
Problem 5 · Classical frequency

Classically, an electron at r = 0.53 Å with v = 2.2 × 10⁶ m/s would radiate at its frequency of revolution. Find it, and explain why the classical spectrum would be continuous.

Hint

ν = v / 2πr.

Full solution
ν = 2.2 × 10⁶ / (2π × 0.53 × 10⁻¹⁰)
= 6.6 × 10¹⁵ Hz
As r shrinks, ν rises smoothly, so every frequency appears.
ν ≈ 6.6 × 10¹⁵ Hz, changing smoothly: a continuous spectrum
Stage 9 · Practice ladder

12 MCQs, from easy to NEET-level

Level

Write the power of n first, then click.

Score: 0 / 12

Stage 10 · Exam corner

How NEET asks this

If the question says…Write this firstThe trap
"classical theory predicts"accelerated charge radiates → spiral in, continuous spectrumSaying the orbit is stable
"angular momentum in nth orbit"L = nh/2πWriting n²h/2π or nh
"radius of nth orbit"r = 0.53 n²/Z ÅUsing n instead of n²
"speed in nth orbit"v = 2.2 × 10⁶ Z/n m/sThinking outer electrons move faster
"energy of nth level"E = −13.6 Z²/n² eVDropping the minus sign or the Z²
"which energy is higher"closer to zero = higherPicking −13.6 eV because 13.6 is bigger
"photon emitted when"hν = E_i − E_f, E_i > E_fSaying emission happens on jumping up
"ratio of time periods"T ∝ n³Using n² because r ∝ n²

Mistakes to avoid

Where this connects next

Lesson 4 turns the energy ladder into the hydrogen spectrum: every line is a jump between two levels, grouped into the Lyman, Balmer and Paschen series. Lesson 5 explains Bohr's strange angular momentum rule with de Broglie's electron waves.

Values used: a₀ = 0.53 Å, E₁ = −13.6 eV, v₁ = 2.2 × 10⁶ m/s, h = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ J s, h/2π = 1.05 × 10⁻³⁴ J s, hc ≈ 1240 eV nm.

0:00 / 0:00

Well done. What next?

Follow the four steps: understand it, remember it, try it, then prove it with past papers.

Lesson 4: Energy levels and spectral series ›✍️ Practise this lesson: Atoms Challenge Q10–13: Bohr's modelRemember it: 5-Minute Revise‹ Previous: Lesson 2: Closest approach and orbit energy‹ Back to chapter🏠 Physics Part 2 home